The Humor Mill

Movie Review: James Gunn’s “Superman” Delivers Heart, Humanity, And A Hero Worth Believing In

Posted Jul 8, 2025

After months of anticipation, “Superman,” the first film in the DC Universe, soars into theaters. Directed by James Gunn, who also wrote the screenplay, the film draws inspiration from the comic book “All-Star Superman” (2005–2008) by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely. Gunn is no stranger to adapting comic book properties and uses this comic as a key template for the movie.

Gunn opens the film up, introducing us to an already established Superman who is in good standing with the world. His alter ego finds his voice as a reporter at the Daily Planet while secretly dating Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan). However, as we all know, Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult) hates Superman for having the power to do everything but not aligning with Luthor’s own beliefs and wants to rid the world of what he sees as an alien menace.

Out of respect for the fans, I want to keep my review spoiler-free, so let’s start with some of the minor gripes. The film kicks off great with a treat for fans as we meet Krypto and are in for more surprises at the Fortress of Solitude. Superman takes a lot of L’s in the film, and I raised my eyebrow at where the film is going. However, within the first forty-five minutes, I was won over.

David Corenswet effectively embodies Superman from the start. The film skips a lengthy origin story, instead showing him already engaged in heroic acts while navigating the complexities of humanity. This focus on introspection, uncertainty, and emotional conflict enhances the film’s appeal. The audience feels Clark’s burdens, both physically and emotionally. Rather than portraying him as infallible, he is shown as a person with fears and insecurities who chooses to display compassion, even in an unworthy world.

Rachel Brosnahan gives a standout performance as Lois Lane, showcasing a mix of traditional qualities and modern confidence that feels fitting for 2025. Rather than just being a supporting character to Superman, she actively works alongside him in the quest for truth. The chemistry between the two characters is remarkable, adding depth to the overall narrative.

As for Lex Luthor, Nicholas Hoult offers a fresh interpretation of the character. His portrayal presents a tech-oriented antagonist—cold, shrewd, and disturbingly realistic. Rather than relying on kryptonite, he commands influence and projects a formidable ego. One particular scene involving Lex and his cronies is a carefully placed jab at Snyder fans.

If you’ve seen the trailer, then you already know that Isabela Merced has a bit part as Kendra Saunders/Hawkgirl and that Nathan Fillion, as Guy Gardner/Green Lantern, also appears as a member of the Justice League. Both are great on screen, but it’s Edi Gathegi’s portrayal of Mr. Terrific that deserves commendation, as he subtly captures the audience’s attention with a performance that’s calculated, poised, and authoritative—a truly compelling presence.

Skyler Gisondo captures the right amount of charm as Jimmy Olsen, even though the character is somewhat underwritten. Wendell Pierce’s soulful bravado shines through as Perry White.

James Gunn skillfully balances visual spectacle with emotional depth. This film transcends the typical Superman narrative, marking the start of a significant and authentic cinematic journey..

Final Grade: A-

Limited tickets may still be available for tonight’s IMAX screening for Prime Members, so check your local theater. Otherwise, catch Superman in theaters this Thursday.

By DERRICK DUNN

Humor Mill Radio LIVE!

READ THE DIGITAL ISSUE!

The Humor Mill Volume 7 Issue 1 March 2023

Join Our Mailing List HERE